Tuesday, September 28, 2010
Comic Book Review: The Walking Dead
I always thought that superheroes were kind of flat as characters. They don't really do anything other than their superhero stuff, and while protecting humankind is cool and important, I'd like to see some kind of character growth somewhere along the way. Yes, Clark loves Lois and it tears him up inside, but it always tears him up inside. Yeah, it's fun the first few times, but after that, it's nauseating.
And seeing as how I didn't really have exposure to any comics other than the superhero variety, I didn't think there was anything out there for me. The Scott Pilgrim series changed my mind slightly, but The Walking Dead changed it completely. While I am a huge fan of some zombie related things, like Resident Evil video games and Zombieland, I'm not a certified freak like some people are. Geronimo suggested the series to me and reassured me that zombies weren't the main focus, which made me feel slightly better. While I resisted for a while, when I finally gave in I wondered why I had waited so long.
The Walking Dead is a post apocalyptic story concerning a few key characters, but mainly revolves around Rick Grimes, a former police officer. He becomes the unwilling leader and voice of morality and reason. But, as the story progresses, his idea of what is right and wrong begins to change as he fights to survive and protect the people he loves.
This story isn't about zombies. It's about people, and what happens to them when they are faced with unbelievable circumstances. My favorite thing about this series is that it feels absolutely real, like if the zombie apocalypse happened tomorrow, this is exactly what would go down. The writing is absolutely stellar, with twists, turns and moments that had me muttering under my breath and sometimes shouting, "Oh. My. God," as I read. In some ways, it feels like a soap opera, especially with some of the relationship dynamics. While that might seem like a turn off, don't let it be; soap operas have an amazing way of capturing human drama, and The Walking Dead is second to none in that department.
Characters are full developed, realized and flawed. It's exciting to read and wonder what they're going to do next, because so many times it's completely unexpected. What's also kind of neat is that you begin to understand some of the more cringe inducing choices they have to make as the situation grows more desperate. I really liked this aspect of the story because I'm pretty sure tough choices would be make more often than not.
If you like stories about human nature, you will love this. If you like well developed characters with real motivations who are constantly faced with hard choices, you will love this. If you like character driven plot, you'll love this. Basically, if you love all that is right with the world, you'll love this series. I've only read up to the 68th issue, and I believe there are eight or nine more I need to read to be caught up.
Added bonus: On October 31st, The Walking Dead TV series will be premiering on AMC. If they can preserve the drama and human emotion that's in the comics, I think it will be a hit. So, pick up the comics and set your DVRs. You can thank me later.
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 12:59 PM 1 comments
Labels: book review, comic book, geronimo, The Walking Dead
Tuesday, September 7, 2010
Book Review: Mockingjay and My Inability to Not be Feminist
Oh Susan Collins, let me count the reasons why I want to punch thee. While I think she had an awesome idea for the Hunger Game Series, I cannot for the life of me figure out why she decided to squander her efforts. The concept is great - children fighting to the death to honor the district from where they came. It features a main female character, Katniss, who is strong willed, not afraid to admit her faults and is accountable for her actions. The backdrop is a post apocalyptic United States, and it is being controlled by a nearly totalitarian government, and Katniss is the key to bringing it all down. Think all of this sounds cool? Yeah?
Well guess what. It's lamesauce. Why, do you ask?
Because it's just another Twilightesque novel where the main female character is basically completely driven by her desires for boys/men. I completely despair over this. Katniss has so many opportunities to do so many wonderful things but yet she is often preoccupied with her friend Gale and Peeta, the boy who fell in love with her for no apparent reason at all. I was hoping that Katniss would kind of grow up in this installment, and while she does in some sense, for the most part she is still the loopy teenage girl who is a slave to her hormones.
I'm not saying that romance or love shouldn't be a part of literature for young readers. That isn't the case. Many of us have learned a lot from our relationships and in some ways it makes us who we are. I object to the unhealthy relationships that are presented in a lot of young adult novels. Love should not hurt. Love should not make you feel as though your life is in danger. Your boyfriend or girlfriend should not look to you to tell them who they are. You shouldn't play games with people's emotions. All of these things are kind of at play here. I actually found myself shaking the book at certain points because it was so frustrating for me to read these things and think about the audience consuming it.
I do like that Katniss, although completely unwillingly, does become a symbol of hope to people who are completely despondent. My only problem with this is that she is absolutely manipulated the entire time by the leaders of the revolution. She bends to their will at almost every turn. Even when she thinks she's tricking them, she isn't; everyone already knows what she's going to do before she does it. I also don't like that she almost never has consequences for her actions. She is driven by her anger to the point where it becomes self-destructive. She is irrational and selfish. At the end of the book, I found myself not really caring what happened to her - the death knell for any main character.
The two main male characters aren't all that great either. Gale and Peeta are both pretty bad examples of men and how they should be. Gale does everything for Katniss and willingly puts up with her abuse because he loves and cares about her. Peeta is the same way in a sense, but he's much more sensitive than Gale. So basically Katniss uses and abuses them as she sees fit because she knows they will both come crawling back to her. Really? Is this appropriate in any sense?
Another thing I took issue with was the absolutely over the top emotional reactions to nearly everything. It was annoying by the time I reached the end. There was also an undercurrent of suicide throughout the entire series, which I thought was highly inappropriate. Oh, life isn't going your way? Why don't you just kill yourself? Absolutely unacceptable.
I read an interview where Collins said that her whole idea behind the book was reality television, and how everything is cut and manipulated to look like something it might not be. She also said that she wanted to show how we are experiencing life differently because of television. I thought this was a cool place for her to write from. I also understand that her audience is a bunch of kids who are going through a lot of physical, emotional and psychological changes and that they love to read this kind of stuff. I just think that she could have done the relationship thing in a different way.
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 4:07 PM 0 comments
Labels: book review, book three, geronimo, mockingjay
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Book Review: The Alchemist
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 5:32 PM 1 comments
Labels: book review, geronimo, The Alchemist
Thursday, August 19, 2010
Book Review: City of Thieves
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 5:15 PM 1 comments
Labels: book review, City of Thieves, geronimo
Monday, August 9, 2010
Book Review: The Shadow of the Wind
I have a thing for Spanish language authors, and it's no secret. I like to be seduced when I read. I like a narrative that grips my mind and incites passion in my heart. I like books that give me a very clear view of the deepest hearts of its characters. I even like things that don't have true happy endings. The Shadow of the Wind by Carlos Ruiz Zafon is all of these things and more.While I enjoyed reading, I was a little disappointed at how Ruiz Zafon chose to reconcile the mystery of Julian Carax. It was a little too easy. I also tend to despair when all of the women in a book are these super sexy temptresses who show up and ruin men's lives, and there was plenty of that in this book too. The only real saving grace is that they were smart, headstrong and not afraid to voice their opinions. It also read like a romance novel in some parts, although it wasn't over the top. No bodice ripping here.
I liked this book and would recommend it to anyone who likes mysteries. It's also loaded with romance as well, but the tragic type that at times to me felt a little unbelievable. I definitely think it's worth the read.
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 6:34 PM 1 comments
Labels: book review, geronimo, The Shadow of the Wind
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
The Hunger Games Book 2 - Catching Fire
Suzanne Collins, how dare you? How dare you make me experience a roller coaster of emotions a la Ron Burgundy? While I question some of her plot points, I have to say that the characters Collins has created in the Hunger Games series have me dying to find out what happens to them. I'm just going to have to distract myself until August 24th when Mockingjay hits store shelves.Posted by Luciana Celestine at 5:55 PM 1 comments
Labels: book review, book two, Catching Fire, geronimo, The Hunger Games
Sunday, July 25, 2010
Book Review: The Hunger Games and Teenage Female Expectation
My friend Geronimo and I have started a book club. Since we're the only members, we alternate book choices. This time around, I chose The Hunger Games, the first in a three part young adult series written by Suzanne Collins (told you I was a little kid at heart). The reviews were glowing and it seemed like something that I'd enjoy, so I gave it a shot. While I'm still kind of on the fence because I haven't finished the series, my initial reaction is that it's pretty slick.
The Hunger Games is an American version of Battle Royale, with the main difference being that it's set in post-apocalyptic America, and the names of every child from the ages of twelve to eighteen are chosen from lottery-style. There are twelve districts with a girl and boy chosen from each, and they must fight until only one has survived. The protagonist, Katniss, is a sixteen year old girl who becomes one of "tributes" when she offers to take the place of her twelve year old sister, Prim, after her name is drawn.
Katniss is a very likeable character. She has a ton of integrity and is as loyal as they come. Her devotion to her sister is touching and she's also very smart. At the beginning of the novel, she's just this regular girl who's trying to help her family survive during very tough times. Katniss and her best friend Gale, a boy she has known since childhood, regularly break the rules and hunt outside of their district. Katniss is more inclined to do what is right than she is to follow the rules. She also doesn't adhere to gender roles.
As the story progresses, Katniss becomes more and more flighty, mostly because of her relationship with Peeta, the male tribute from her district. After I finished the book, I found this a little disappointing. The recommended reading age is grades seven through nine, and I'm not sure if any pre-teen or young teenage girls need their heads filled with any more of the stereotypical gender roles that Katniss begins to fall into as the relationship develops. Not to give too much away, but there are times when I shook my head at this smart, strong teenage girl.
I think that a good story should be transformative for the reader, and I think that Collins may have missed her opportunity to give young women a new type of heroine. Katniss drastically changes from the beginning of the novel to the end, although I did try to take into account that she did experience something very traumatic and that her decisions may have been based on the the stress of being in the arena, fighting to survive. I am very interested to see where Collins take Katniss next - I certainly believe that she has a lot of potential, and I hope that she becomes the kind of heroine that makes the girls who read this realize that it's ok to be strong.
Overall, I think that this is a pretty solidly written book. It moves along at a good pace and there is a sense of profluence throughout. There were times where I couldn't put it down because I had to know what happened next. The style is a little juvenille, but it is from the viewpoint of a sixteen year old and it's written for thirteen year olds, so I couldn't expect much there. Even though I was slightly disappointed at the end of the first book, Collins has hooked me and I need to keep reading, which says a lot.
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 8:25 AM 0 comments
Labels: book one, book review, geronimo, The Hunger Games
Monday, July 19, 2010
Book Review: "I Know This Much Is True" and The Issue of Character Torture
Most of my writing projects have started as a result of a character coming to mind. For instance, my thesis at Wilkes University was brought about by a writing prompt where a child was faced with something emotionally scarring, and almost a year later, I had written 325 pages that ended up sort of being about her. As I wrote, her mother became center stage, and she had a bunch of pretty crappy stuff happen to her, too. Throughout, I tried to keep the plot simple so that I could focus on my characters. Whenever I'd get stuck, I'd throw more and more wrenches into my main character's gears, hoping that it would move things along.
I didn't realize how ridiculous this was until I went back to revise. What had I been thinking? By trying to power through some less inspired sections, I had basically written a very silly, unbelievable book. Some of the scenarios were downright laughable. But what really made me realize this was Wally Lamb's book, I Know This Much Is True. While very well written, it was also very hard to believe that this one character experienced all of these things that might not happen to any of us in our lifetimes.
As part of a little book agreement between a friend and I, we've been picking books, reading them and discussing them. IKTMIT started out perfectly for me. I was into the characters and the story. Everything felt really authentic, and I was really relating to Dominick's plight as a caretaker. Truly a man with the world on his shoulders, I felt his Italian duty to his family attitude all the way to my bones.
But then, something weird happened. Something out of his character. Something that didn't make sense. Then, the weird somethings started popping up like summer afternoon thunderstorms. They were all over the place, By the time I reached the end of the book, I had no idea what I had read. Basically, poor Dominick (you can't help but pity him) had been on the recieving end of some pretty terrible things, victimized by the author the entire way through the text. There are some bright spots for him, though very few and far between. In fact, at the end of the book I found it hard to believe that his story ended where and with whom it did.
I felt as though Dominick's main issue, the care of his schizophrenic identical twin brother, to be enough for him to have to endure as a character. I don't understand why Lamb felt the overwhelming urge to give him more crosses to bear. Lamb's decisions to make the unbelievable happen to this man over and over again jolted me from my waking dream while reading this book, making it nearly impossible to enjoy it. The things that happened to Dominick felt completely contrived, and part of me felt as though Lamb just didn't have the heart to kill his darlings.
There is a good story in there somewhere amongst the 900+ pages. Cut away two-thirds of that and maybe you have something that will move you, change your life. As it stands, IKTMIT for me was largely a very long and drawn out disappointment.
Posted by Luciana Celestine at 7:23 PM 0 comments
Labels: book review, I Know This Much Is True